“Achievement cannot be awarded; it must be earned.”
Posted on: Wednesday, October 31st, 2007 in: UncategorizedA test of expedience
Special educators push their students to fantastic heights
Editor, The Times:
Thanks very much to The Times’ Kate Riley for her honesty about her young son’s ability [”Congrats, education officials, you’ve weakened WASL standards,” Times editorial column, Oct. 29]. It is a bitter pill to swallow. We understand, as our granddaughter was a preemie and has many adversities to overcome, some of which she may never accomplish. We aren’t about to tell her she can’t, because she has surprised us all many times.
At the same time, having spent eight years on a local school board, I have seen the fantasy of giving kids grades they did not earn. It furthers their handicap rather than mitigating it, as they too often fail then to understand that they have a challenge to overcome.
Maintaining reasonable standards, that an ordinary person would have a hard time arguing with, is critical to kids’ success.
We wish Riley the best, and will pray that her strength will remain with her as she struggles through the years.
- Al and Linda King, OlympiaWhat goes up
I am a special-education teacher and have reached a point where I have to laugh to keep from crying over what I am required to do to make sure my students “meet standard.” I have a self-contained, multiage class of students with multiple disabilities of various types who all function at a level significantly lower than a typical 2- or 3-year-old, some less than one year.
The rules have changed over the last several years so that now my colleagues and I are required to assemble portfolios showing that our students are making progress in line with the GLEs (grade-level expectations) in math, reading, writing and, in some grades, science.
I have actually been told that when a student lifts his/her head, it can be evaluated as science because it is working against gravity.
I can honestly say I would not resent the extra time and effort this takes all of us if the results actually helped to improve our ability to develop and implement functional and appropriate programs for our students and their families. But they do not even come close.
The sad part of all this is that there are apparently a number of people out there who think this is all a wonderful idea.
- Robert Connors, SeattleFear is a hard teacher
Kate Riley demonstrated a lot of courage to write “Congrats, education officials … ”
The WASL “leadership” has shown so little leadership and nearly no common sense. Achievement cannot be awarded; it must be earned.
The extreme liberalism here in Washington has significantly devalued our currency among serious educators and academics who just shake their heads and are cowed by their colleagues into little or no comment.
- Richard Starr, SammamishNo counting on a hand
I, too, am a supporter of the WASL and of alternative ways to pass and am glad to hear that the state is working on accountability measures for the special-ed department. They are long overdue.
I always believed that the No Child Left Behind Act was created not for the majority of kids who will graduate high school if they want to, but for kids who have learning differences that require a different approach to achieve their full potential.
I have yet to see how No Child Left Behind has made any difference for these kids; in fact, it may be hurting them as their IEPs are written, especially during their high-school years, to fit into what the school wants their records to show.
It’s very hard to be a Blue Ribbon School and have many special-ed students capable of passing the WASL. If affluent Blue Ribbon Schools can’t do it, which school can?
Parents who can afford to pay for support readily do so but, unfortunately, many parents are not able to, nor are these the parents who will hold the school accountable.
- Donna Shuman, MedinaFirefighting tools
The blame retardant
Seeking private solutions for responding to disasters is a smart and efficient way to augment underfunded public services. If the owners of expensive homes utilize private firefighters to protect their property [”Pay a premium, get a private firefighter: Mansions of moneyed saved from flames,” Business & Technology, Oct. 30], that allows public firefighters to concentrate their efforts in less-advantaged neighborhoods.
Instead of criticizing the wealthy for protecting their property, we should be applauding what could be a valuable public-private partnership for responding to disasters. Contrary to [author of “The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism”] Naomi Klein’s statement that “survival shouldn’t be a luxury item,” these are material goods rather than human lives that are largely at stake.
If it is true that “more frugal” homeowners could purchase effective fire retardants for $1,000, less than the cost of a new wide-screen TV, perhaps more people in disaster-prone areas should consider doing so.
- Michele Leonard, KenmoreA damper lock
Reader Jonathan Ursin of Seattle writes, “However, the only reason the government is taking any action in Southern California is because the government feels an obligation to help people who have money … Compare this response to Hurricane Katrina … ” [”Things we found in the fire,” Northwest Voices, Oct. 30.]
Actually, Louisiana did not have its act together locally, but Californians do. Louisiana is right now learning its lesson and citizens have voted in a Republican governor because they are sick of the party-all-night, take-no-responsibility-for-our-citizens approach.
They have received billions in donations from people around the country and will rebuild with a more-responsible governor.
- Barbara Atwood, CovingtonThe old smoke screen
Michael Chertoff, head of Homeland Security, is outraged when he finds out that FEMA faked a press conference [about the fires in California]? [”Chertoff blisters FEMA over fake media event,” News, Oct. 28.]
Where has his outrage been for the past six years while this administration has obfuscated, cherry-picked, misrepresented, misled and just plain lied to the American public about almost everything it has done?
- Mark Nielson, RentonCarriage license
The blushing ride
Regarding “Streetcar on track” [Local News, Oct. 26], to my ears, the only proper name for the $51 million South Lake Union Trolley is “S.L.U.T.”
- Christal Wood, Seattle
